Emma Jonson How do you comment on a review paper?
Summary
- Give positive feedback first.
- Briefly summarize what the paper is about and what the findings are.
- Try to put the findings of the paper into the context of the existing literature and current knowledge.
- Indicate the significance of the work and if it is novel or mainly confirmatory.
How do you list a publication under review?
Do list your manuscripts under review. For your job market CV (i.e. the one you send to search committees), list the journal where a paper is under review regardless of its status (submitted, under review, revise and resubmit, or accepted pending minor revisions).
How do you format a review article?
Article review format – how to apply it correctly
- Title page.
- Title.
- Your name.
- Date.
- Abstract: It should contain approximately 200 to 300 words.
- Introduction: Write the topic of the study, which serves as the identification sentence.
- Body: This includes the subtopics that you are addressing.
What should be included in a review paper?
This guide explains each section of a review paper and gives specific information about what should be included in each.
- Title Page. On the title page include the title, your name, and the date.
- Abstract. An abstract is a brief summary of your review.
- Introduction.
- Discussion.
- Conclusions.
- References.
What is a review format?
Typically, reviews include an abstract, an introduction, a literature review section, sometimes a methods section if you have specifics to include, and a discussion and conclusion section.
How do you write a response to a review?
Ten simple rules for writing a response to reviewers
- Rule 1: Provide an overview, then quote the full set of reviews.
- Rule 2: Be polite and respectful of all reviewers.
- Rule 3: Accept the blame.
- Rule 4: Make the response self-contained.
- Rule 5: Respond to every point raised by the reviewer.
What should be included in a review article?
What is a review article? A review article, also called a literature review, is a survey of previously published research on a topic. It should give an overview of current thinking on the theme and, unlike an original research article, won’t present new experimental results.
Can you cite a review article in your paper?
Unlike typical research articles, review articles do not present any original primary research. For this reason, some assignments may not allow you to directly cite a review article in your paper. However, you can still use the article to get a general understanding of the field and to find important primary research articles.
How to find a review in a journal?
Search for your discipline or subject area, and Review (e.g., Sociology Review or Psychology Review ). On the results page, browse the list of journals, and then click on a title to visit the journal’s website. In both Google Scholar and ArticlesPlus you can add review, “literature review”, “annual review” or “review article” to your search terms.
What to consider when reviewing a Yale Journal article?
1 What is the overall aim of the research being presented? 2 Have the Authors clearly stated what they have identified in their research? 3 Are the aims of the manuscript and the results of the data clearly and concisely stated in the abstract?