Emma Jonson What are the chances of paper acceptance after major revision?
Papers having two reviewers’ recommendations to accept and minor revision have much greater chance of acceptance (more than 98%) than papers receiving two reviewers’ recommendations that include a major revision and a reject or two rejections (which results in an acceptance rate of less than 5%): (Figure 1).
Is revise and resubmit a rejection?
A ‘Reject and resubmit’ decision is very similar to ‘Revise and resubmit. ‘ It indicates that the editor has seen some merit in your study, but it is not publishable in its current form. Usually, it would require extensive revision, in most cases, adding new experiments or redoing the data analysis.
What is considered major revision?
In short, “major revisions” means you’ve got work to do on your manuscript, but you’re still very much in the game. Your target journal’s editor has sent your manuscript to two or more peer reviewers. At least one of them felt that some substantial changes were needed before the journal can publish your work.
Can a paper get rejected after a major revision?
The probability of major revised paper is more than 50%. If one addresses the reviewers/editors comment properly, the paper acceptance chance is more. A very few papers rejected after revisions. Rejection is only possible in rare cases when authors ignore required modifications by reviewers/editor.
Can a paper be rejected after minor revision?
Sometimes a revised manuscript goes out to a new reviewer, so although the minor revisions may have been done in a thorough manner, the new may identify other issues with the manuscript, which might result in a recommendation to reject.
Can major revision be rejected?
Yes your paper does have a chance to be accepted. If it didn’t, you would not have gotten a major revision, but rather a rejection. Note the editor can choose to accept a paper even if the reviewers recommend rejection. It doesn’t happen often, but it’s possible.
What is the difference between major and minor revision?
Changes of an administrative nature that do not require the submission of graphic exhibits are considered minor revisions and incur in a minor revision fee. Changes that require revised plans to be submitted and/or modify calculations are considered major revisions and incur a major revision fee.
Can a paper be rejected with two major revisions?
In this case, the paper should probably be rejected, because two major revisions are not allowed. HOWEVER, an editor can say: “I reject this paper, but you should go through a major revision and submit a new/different paper.”
What should the handling editor do if an article is rejected?
If the article is rejected or sent back for either major or minor revision, the handling editor should include constructive comments from the reviewers to help the author improve the article. At this point, reviewers should also be sent an email or letter letting them know the outcome of their review.
When to consider a rejection from a reviewer?
In rare cases when ‘fraud’ and ‘plagiarism’ is suspected by the reviewer (which the editor has missed), the reviewer rejects. these are the most important author should consider before/while submission, otherwise there is a fair possibility of receiving rejection, major revision, and minor revision comments from the editor.
What happens if an article is rejected by a peer review?
If accepted, the paper is sent to production. If the article is rejected or sent back for either major or minor revision, the handling editor should include constructive comments from the reviewers to help the author improve the article. At this point, reviewers should also be sent an email or letter letting them know the outcome of their review.