Emma Jonson What are the possible reasons as to why a concept paper can be denied or rejected?
The reasons for a paper being rejected once it has been reviewed fall mainly into two categories: (1) problems with the research; and (2) problems with the writing/presentation of the paper. A paper may be rejected because of problems with the research on which it is based.
How do I get my paper rejected or not?
How to get your paper rejected
- Getting started. Start by looking at your data randomly.
- Questions and answers. In the abstract, ask as many questions as you can.
- Descriptions. Describe your methods in random order.
- What you know. Critically discuss your results, comparing them with others’.
- The right answer.
- A work of art.
What did the second reviewer say about my paper?
The comments of the second reviewer seemed disrespectful and misinformed. His/her comments were written in a way that suggests that I am stupid and what I did is just rubbish. He/she gave me some comments (the reasons why he/she wants to reject my paper).
What should you do if your paper is rejected without peer review?
Rejection is part of every academic’s life. Still, getting a paper rejected can sting. Or it is at least annoying because it means extra work. But what should you do after your paper was rejected without peer review? Should you submit your paper to another journal as it is? Revise it before? Write an appeal letter to the editor?
When to consider a rejection from a reviewer?
In rare cases when ‘fraud’ and ‘plagiarism’ is suspected by the reviewer (which the editor has missed), the reviewer rejects. these are the most important author should consider before/while submission, otherwise there is a fair possibility of receiving rejection, major revision, and minor revision comments from the editor.
When to respond to comments from peer reviewers?
Responding to the comments peer reviewers offer when they assess your research paper can be as challenging as writing the original manuscript, especially when the necessity of revising your paper to resolve problems is considered as well.