on Contributing

What is the purpose of a reviewer?

What is the purpose of a reviewer?

What do reviewers do, and why? Reviewers evaluate article submissions to journals based on the requirements of that journal, predefined criteria, and the quality, completeness and accuracy of the research presented.

How do I write a comment as a reviewer?

Avoid overly negative wording or personal comments, point out the main strengths of the manuscript as well as its weaknesses, and suggest specific ways to fix the problems you identify. Also, avoid making overly brief and direct comments, as these can give your report an unfriendly tone.

How do you review a reviewer paper?

Reviewing a paper

  1. Don’t start your review when you are not in a good mood.
  2. Be responsible and do it in time.
  3. Try to write in a simple and clear English.
  4. Be open to new ideas and don’t try to take the author to what you want.
  5. Complicated papers are not necessarily of good quality.

What are the duties of a reviewer of a manuscript?

Reviewers are primarily employed to go through the research papers submitted by the authors for publishing. Their prime object is to find discrepancies in those papers. They give their valuable opinions in an article. They have to assess the manuscripts thoroughly.

Who can be a reviewer?

Some journal insist that you must a PhD holder in order to be a reviewer. Most ISI/SCOPUS journals are very particular with their reviewers. You don’t have to worry too much on this as many journal will have TWO to THREE reviewers for articles sent by a prospective authors.

How do you write a good review report?

Summary

  1. Begin with any positive feedback you have – if you start off on a positive note, authors will be more likely to read your review.
  2. Try to put the findings of the paper into the context of the existing literature and current knowledge.

How do you give a review?

But with most types of reviews, there’s a simple structure you can stick to in order to help you get started:

  1. 1 A thesis. Before you write, make sure you know the general message you want to convey.
  2. 2 Likes and dislikes. In the most glowing review, you may not include any dislikes.
  3. 3 Your recommendation.

How do we write a review?

Top tips for writing a review

  1. 1 Read, watch, or listen to the work more than once.
  2. 2 Provide essential information.
  3. 3 Understand your audience.
  4. 4 Take a stand.
  5. 5 Explain how you’re judging the work.
  6. 6 Introduce evidence to support your criteria.
  7. 7 Know the conventions of the genre.
  8. 8 Compare and contrast.

How do you conduct a review process?

So, here’s how to conduct a business process review in four steps:

  1. Identify and map out your current processes. Start by defining the business process ‘as is’.
  2. Analyse them by talking to Stakeholders (Don’t forget your customers).
  3. Map out your new plan and objectives.
  4. Find out how technology fits into your new plan.

How do you become a paid reviewer?

There are plenty of websites and services that you can sign up for if you want to get paid to write reviews.

  1. LifePoints. LifePoints is a website that pays users to complete surveys.
  2. InboxDollars.
  3. American Consumer Opinion.
  4. Start a Review Blog.
  5. UserTesting.
  6. Review Stream.
  7. YouTube BrandConnect.
  8. Influence Central.

How can I be a good reviewer?

There are quite a few ways to shift bad behaviors and habits of reviewers to become not just good, but great peer reviewers.

  1. Mind the Time.
  2. Be Intentional.
  3. Read the Guidelines and Scope.
  4. Educate and Grow Your Community.
  5. Say No (and recommend others)
  6. Be Bold and Constructive.
  7. Get Credit.

What was the reviewer’s comment on the report?

Comment:This was an excellent report on very thorough research. The literature review was thorough, the methodology was painstakingly thorough and incorporated the use of sufficient numbers of samples in dust size analysis and explosion tests.

Is the name of the reviewer disclosed to the author?

The reviewer’s name isn’t disclosed to the author. Double-anonymous review (also called ‘double-blind peer review’). The identity of the reviewers and the authors aren’t disclosed. Open review. Both the author and reviewer names are disclosed.

What’s the role of a reviewer in a book?

The ultimate decision always rests with the editor but reviewers play a significant role in determining the outcome. Reviewing is a time-intensive process – writing a review report can be almost as much work as writing a manuscript! – but it is very worthwhile for the reviewer as well as for the community.

What are the guidelines for reviewing an article?

Also, reviewers must not use any information in the article they review to their advantage without proper disclosure and citation. Reviewers should contact the journal if they would like to contact the authors or if they are interested in using any of the material they have reviewed.