Emma Jonson When can a scientific manuscript be rejected?
This type of rejection typically happens quickly—within 1‒2 weeks of submission—and is made by the journal editor. Editors reject manuscripts at this stage for one or more technical reasons: The manuscript is missing essential elements or sections required by the journal.
How do you deal with a rejection manuscript?
Here are the most common options for next steps after rejection:
- Appeal the rejection.
- Resubmit to the same journal.
- Make changes and submit to a different journal.
- Make no changes and submit to another journal.
- File the manuscript away and never resubmit it.
What does constant rejection do to a person?
Because of their fears and expectations, people with rejection sensitivity tend to misinterpret, distort, and overreact to what other people say and do. They may even respond with hurt and anger.
What are the causes of manuscript rejection with examples for rejection or revisions if possible?
9 Common Reasons for Rejection
- The manuscript fails the technical screening.
- The manuscript does not fall within the journal’s Aims and Scope.
- The research topic isn’t of great enough significance.
- The research is over-ambitious.
- A clear hypothesis hasn’t been established.
- The manuscript is incomplete.
When should one recommend rejection of a manuscript?
For example, if a paper has methodology problems but is otherwise solid “major revisions” is an easy decision, as is the case if the manuscript presents clear examples of plagiarism or results that do not advance the field. However, there are cases where the proper decision to make for a manuscript is not clear.
Can a paper be rejected with two major revisions?
In this case, the paper should probably be rejected, because two major revisions are not allowed. HOWEVER, an editor can say: “I reject this paper, but you should go through a major revision and submit a new/different paper.”
Can a minor revision be accepted by an editor?
Minor revision may undergo referee evaluation; however, in most cases, the editor accepts the paper without sending the revised manuscript to the reviewer. In fine, a careful revision, whether it’s for major or minor, brings your paper accepted by the editor.
How many revisions can you make to a manuscript?
Reviewers or editors should not be expected to be “manuscript detectives” to find all of the revisions made by the authors. 32 Authors will make everyone’s life easier by spelling out the changes the first time around.